Why Business Transformation Fails: The Truth About Frameworks and the Role of the Business Transformator

Like this Post? Share it 😁

What its like to work with a HOBA Business Transformator

Why Your Framework Isn't the Problem—It's How You're Using It

"70% of business transformation projects fail."

You’ve probably heard this statistic before, right?

It’s tossed around in boardrooms and strategy sessions as a cautionary tale.

But here’s the kicker—this failure rate isn’t because we lack frameworks or methodologies.

It’s because we rely too heavily on them and forget the most crucial element of transformation: context.

I’m Heath Gascoigne, and I’ve spent over 15 years leading business transformations across industries. From working with the UK government to transforming FTSE100 companies, I’ve seen firsthand why so many projects miss the mark.

It’s not because frameworks like TOGAF or SAFe are inherently flawed—they have their place.

The real issue lies in how we apply these frameworks and who’s leading the charge.

Heres what we’ll cover (click the links to skip to the section below):

NB – Click to expand images 📸

Table of Contents

The Problem with Popular Frameworks

Let’s be clear: TOGAF and SAFe are excellent at what they were designed for.

TOGAF is fantastic for technology architecture, while SAFe shines in agile software development.

But here’s where it goes off the rails—these frameworks have been marketed as the end-all, be-all solutions for business transformation.

And that’s simply not true.

These frameworks became popular not because of their success rates in business transformation, but because of their marketing.

They’re backed by big consulting firms, promoted at conferences, and taught in certification courses.

But popularity doesn’t equal effectiveness.

You see, the industry is flooded with consultants who have rote-learned these frameworks.

They follow the book to the letter without understanding the nuanced layers, language, and levels within an organisation.

And this is where things start to go south.

Frameworks Don’t Transform—People Do

Here’s the reality: A framework is just a tool. It’s not a silver bullet.

The true differentiator in successful transformation projects is the skill of those leading it.

I call these individuals Business Transformators.

They’re not just following a framework; they’re adapting and applying it based on the unique context of each organisation.

A Business Transformator knows how to navigate the 3-L’s of business transformation—layers, language, and levels.

They understand that the C-suite speaks in terms of market share and competitive positioning, while operations folks talk about process efficiency and KPIs.

Implementation layers focus on the nitty-gritty details like system integrations and user requirements.

Each layer has its own language, its own focus, and requires a tailored approach.

Most consultants today, unfortunately, haven’t grasped this.

They’re trained to follow frameworks by the book.

They lack situational awareness and fail to apply methods and frameworks appropriately and proportionately for the context.

That’s why we end up with “interesting but sadly, useless” blueprints hanging in war rooms.

The War Room: Where Dreams Go to Die

Ever been in a “war room”?

You know, that room plastered with blueprints and diagrams, celebrating the pinning up of artefacts like it’s a great achievement?

Here’s the hard truth: If those blueprints don’t lead to actionable change, they’re just wall decor.

I’ve seen it happen time and time again—pretty presentations and “marketecture” that justify consulting fees but deliver zero value.

It’s all for show.

These artefacts serve as a way to bamboozle stakeholders with jargon and acronyms, making them feel like something substantial is happening.

The stakeholders nod in agreement, partly out of respect for the consultant’s “years of experience” and partly because they don’t want to appear less knowledgeable.

They agree to proposals they don’t fully understand and then, when the consultants rotate out, they go back to business as usual.

And what’s the result?

Transformation projects that deliver nothing but PowerPoint slides and glossy diagrams.

FREE Business Transformation Strategy Call

BOOK YOUR FREE STRATEGY CALL! 📞

Unlock the roadmap to your business transformation success. Schedule a free strategy call with our experts to align your strategy, architecture, and operations for real change. Let’s create a tailored approach that fits your needs and sets you on the path to success. 🚀

👀 "The biggest myth in business transformation? That frameworks like TOGAF and SAFe are the answer to all your problems. They're not. It's not the framework; it's how you use it." #BusinessTransformation #FrameworkMyth #TOGAF #SAFe 💥

The Business Transformator: The Real Change Agent

This is where the Business Transformator steps in.

They don’t get caught up in jargon or frameworks for the sake of frameworks.

They understand that successful transformation is about understanding the organisation’s unique context and applying tools, techniques, and frameworks appropriately.

They’re part-strategist, part-designer, part-collaborator, and part-negotiator.

They know that a one-size-fits-all approach doesn’t work.

A true Business Transformator engages with each layer of the organisation.

They understand the C-suite’s high-level strategic goals and translate them into actionable plans for operations and implementation.

They know when to use a framework like TOGAF for its strengths in technology architecture and when to adapt another approach to address business needs.

They use the framework as a guide, not a rulebook.

Actionable Insights: What You Can Do Today

Don’t take a framework at face value just because it’s popular. Question whether it’s the right tool for your unique business context.
Before diving into a transformation project, understand your organization’s layers, language, and levels. What is the C-suite focused on? What does the operations team need to succeed? Where are the gaps?
Adopt the mindset of a Business Transformator. It’s not about following frameworks to the letter; it’s about applying them proportionately and appropriately. Your job is to bridge the gap between strategy and execution, tailoring your approach to each situation.
If you see pretty presentations and blueprints that don’t lead to actionable change, call it out. Transformation is about delivering value, not just creating artefacts.

Your Next Step: The Business Transformation Health Check

Get a FREE online health check of your business transformation efforts
Get a FREE online health check of your business transformation efforts 👉

Ready to break free from the cycle of using popular but ineffective methods?

It’s time to think beyond the framework and focus on real, actionable transformation.

At HOBA Tech, we’ve developed an online Business Transformation Health Check to assess your current state, identify what’s working, and pinpoint what needs fixing.

You’ll get an overall score and individual scores against each element of the transformation journey to help you prioritise where to focus.

Take the Health Check now and start transforming the right way! 👉 take the health check

Final Thoughts

TOGAF's single focus is I.T 💻
TOGAF's single focus is I.T 💻

🚨 "Stop relying on 'popular' frameworks just because they're well-marketed. A true Business Transformator understands that success comes from applying tools appropriately and proportionately for the context, not blindly following a rulebook." #BusinessTransformator #HOBA #TransformationSuccess 🚀

Frameworks have their place, but they’re not the answer to successful business transformation.
 
It’s the skill of the Business Transformator—someone who understands context, can adapt frameworks appropriately, and drives real, sustainable change—that makes the difference.
 
Stop relying on the book and start thinking.
 
Challenge the status quo, and let’s start transforming for success.

Ready to Transform? Get Started Today!

Ready to elevate your transformation journey?

Contact us today for a free consultation and learn how to become a true Business Transformator.

Let’s transform—together. 🚀

Is Your Business Transformation on Track? 🚀

Ensure your business transformation is heading in the right direction. Our online FREE Business Transformation Health Check, learn your score, get insights to identify gaps and unlock your full potential. Don’t leave success to chance—take action today! 🔐

💡 "Most war rooms are filled with ‘marketecture’—interesting but sadly, useless. If your blueprints don't lead to real change, they’re just wall decor." #WarRoomReality #BusinessArchitecture #TransformationTruths 🎯

At the end of the day, the key to successful business transformation isn’t just about the frameworks you use—it’s about how you use them. 📊

It’s about understanding the context, applying tools and techniques appropriately, and driving real, sustainable change.

The Business Transformator plays a pivotal role in this process, guiding your organisation through the layers, language, and levels to ensure every aspect of your business is aligned for success. 🌟

If you’re ready to move beyond the status quo and want a framework that actually works for your business, it’s time to take action.

HOBA Tech is here to provide you with the tools, skills, and mindset needed for a true transformation journey.

☎️ Ready to get started? Contact us today for a FREE consultation and learn how we can empower your business to transform effectively and efficiently.

🚀 Don’t forget to take advantage of our FREE Business Transformation Health Check for a customized report on where you stand and actionable steps to improve.

📘 Plus, grab your free copy of The Business Transformation Playbook using the code TRUTHBOMB (Value $49.00) and discover how HOBA can make a real difference in your transformation journey. 👉  Download here

Let’s transform—together. 🚀

Signature-Heath

Heath Gascoigne

P.S. If you want to join our Business Transformator community of 2,000+ like-minded Business Transformators, join the community on the Business Transformator Facebook Group here.

P.P.S. If you want to learn more about business transformation, check out The Business Transformation Playbook here.

For more information, visit https://www.hoba.tech

Picture of Heath Gascoigne

Heath Gascoigne

Hi, I'm Heath, the founder of HOBA TECH and host of The Business Transformation Podcast. I help Business Transformation Consultants, Business Designers and Business Architects transform their and their clients' business and join the 30% club that succeed. Join me on this journey.

Can't get enough real insights? Subscribe to Transformology®!​

We’ll send jargon free insights that you can actually use to transform your business straight to your inbox once a week. 

Work Smarter, not Harder!

Subscribe to Transformology®

Connect with Us

Trending

Mastering Business Transformation Lessons from Lean Six Sigma Expert Tom West

Most business transformations fail, not because of the frameworks but due to how they’re

Read More »
HOBA Tech and Heath Gascoigne Partner with Cigna Health to Drive Strategic Alignment and Business Transformation

HOBA Tech and founder Heath Gascoigne join Cigna Health as Senior Advisor (Architecture) to

Read More »
Blackwells stocks The Business Transformation Playbook across UK universities national wide

The Business Transformation Playbook is now officially available at Blackwell’s bookstores across UK university

Read More »
Business Transformation Training - HOBA Is different

Become a Master of Business Transformation

Learn about Business-led Business Transformation
using the proven 6-step agile transformation framework
trusted by the UK Government, FTSE-100 and
fast growing companies

What's HOBA®?

HOBA® is the new way to transform organisations and the answer to the 70% failure rate of business and digital transformation projects today.

Learn more about HOBA®

Are you a consultant,
team or organisation
embarking on your
transformation and
want to move from the
model of transforming
business?

Join our free webinar
and learn ‘How to
maximum the return
on your
transformations,
improve service
delivery with less
effort, less time & cost
and increased profits!’

AGILE 1.0 ... 2.0

Successful Business Transformation starts here

More Articles

Vector Globe Design for Business Transformation

Get content like this sent directly to your inbox!

Scroll to Top

Get a FREE Health Check of your Business Transformation Efforts

✅ Complete the Scorecard
✅ Get Your Report
✅ Start Transforming

HOBA Business Transformation Checklist

Wait. Unlock Your Business Transformation Potential!

Don’t leave empty-handed! Get our exclusive guide on effective business transformation strategies for 2024-2025. Discover actionable insights and proven methods to lead your organisation to success.

Webinar has eneded, Join Waitlist

The Webinar has ended and Please join waitlist to contact with us.

Apologies, The Scorecard is currently down!

We are working to get it restored. Leave your details below to be notified when we got it back up again!

Cookie-Man.svg

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website.