🏆 Limited Time Offer: Get Agile Starter for Only $197! 🚀

Only hours left. Get 80% Off Agile Starter or Plus! 🏆


To Pilot Your Business Transformation Or Not That Is The Question

Like this Post? Share it 😁

To Pilot or Not to Pilot - That is the Question

In the blog post “To Pilot Your Business Transformation or Not, That Is the Question”, HOBA Tech delves into the complexities of piloting business transformations.

The post discusses the importance of identifying anticipated or perceived risks after executing a pilot and the role of piloting as a stakeholder and expectation management tool.

It also highlights the significance of evaluating risks reasonably to instil confidence in the transformation process.

The post further emphasises the need for a process-driven approach to transformation, rather than solely relying on technology.

Heres what we’ll cover (click the links to skip to the section below):

NB – Click to expand images 📸

What are the signs that your business transformation is in trouble? Have you noticed the tell-tale signs only when it is already too late?

All these could have been avoided if you had followed the principles to carry out a successful business transformation.

These have been discussed in-depth in our previous posts “Signs your Business Transformation is in Trouble” and “The Keys to a Successful Business Transformation”.

In this post, we will discuss whether to have a ‘Pilot’ (project) before carrying out a full-blown business transformation or not and what are the fall-outs of doing or not doing so.

Piloting is the equivalent in the business environment of the general concept of “trying before buying”. This is why piloting is critical as it helps to test the waters before any business transformation is implemented.

So, what are the benefits of piloting, using an MVP – Minimum Viable Product to ‘try before you buy’ – as against a full-blown implementation or TOM – Target Operating Model from the get-go?

Lets get into it!

Confirmed Benefits

We start with the assumption that every transformation project is only be considered for some perceived benefits gained or realised from it. This is often a subject of great debate within organizations when they struggle to understand or quantify what exactly are those benefits and when should they expect them.

A pilot project is a handy but sometimes vital opportunity both discover and validate whether or to the degree that both the final product or service, and the implementation method (to implement the end solution) would realise or start to realise those benefits through limited-scope applications.

However, although it is important that the scope of the pilot is reasonably large or to the scale that it is representative of the full scale of the business transformation, it should be tested on a small population of total Users and End Users as to not affect the whole organisation, should it all go wrong.

Risk Management

Regardless of the nature of an organization, there is always an element of risk in implementing something new. This is true whether the change is implementing a new process or new technology. Risk is always a major factor in these circumstances.

A pilot is an opportunity to implement the solution in a limited manner so that any adverse fall-out can be kept within restricted boundaries without affecting the whole organization.

HOBATech Logo

6-Steps to Business Transformation Success


Heath Gascoigne - Speaker

👏 "Piloting is an effective stakeholder management, and stakeholder expectation management tool, albeit it can be lengthy and costly." 🎯💼 #Piloting #StakeholderManagement

After the execution of the pilot, the anticipated or perceived risks at the beginning of the project can be more accurately identified now in relation to the whole planned transformation.

Stakeholder Management

The biggest obstacle to change is not process or technology, it is employees. We covered this is another post. Piloting is an effective stakeholder management, and stakeholder expectation management tool, albeit it can be lengthy and costly. Pilots helps stakeholders with the ‘seeing the unseen’. People, by nature are risk adverse, and not like change, so piloting is a way to address this by allowing them to “believe it (i.e. the solution) when they see it”.

No amount of “selling” of the solution to them with the ‘description’ of the benefits, statistics or ROI is arguable more effective than seeing the results by being involved in the pilot themselves; reported from those involved (fellow team and/or staff members) or ‘champions’ of the transformation itself.

In a nutshell, the table below summaries some of the aspects the pilot aims to address:          

The Different 5W1H Aspects the Pilot Aims to Address ✈️
The Different 5W1H Aspects the Pilot Aims to Address ✈️

In spite of these obvious benefits of piloting, there is a general perception that the additional time and cost incurred on testing the solution could have been put to better use in implementing the transformation.

Pros and Cons

The point then is to see whether to pilot or no-pilot. The pros and cons of piloting have already been seen here. To decide which step to take, the pros and cons of full implementation need to be investigated. Unfortunately (depending on your risk tolerance, and your organisations appetite for risk), to go ahead without a pilot is to proceed with the full implementation and process of transformation without testing the implementation, and final solution in the Organisation, with the market and customers beforehand.

The advantage here is the potential to be a (relatively) quicker implementation as there is no testing (i.e. pilot) phase required. This option is more suited when there are time constraints to implement quick(er); the Organisation has previous experience in similar transformations they are confident in their solution they are implementing, the method or approach they are using for implementation, or have successfully done a similar transformation of the same or similar scale and complexity before.

On the flip side, there is a possibility that the full operation of the implemented capabilities does not go through as planned and this will lead to lost time, money, and resources. There is always a high risk of both operational and implementation risk when ‘no-pilot’ are undertaken.

The decision of pilot or no-pilot will ultimately depend on the perceived pros and cons of both the pilot ‘solution’ and pilot ‘implementation’, weighted against the perceived risks of a full ‘solution’ and full ‘implementation’ and the relative advantages (and disadvantages) – namely time, quality, cost gained or mitigated from piloting.

The process to get the Organisation and the program to the position where they understand what is required for the pilot first, is a robust Target Operating Model (TOM) design, based off a structured understanding of the Current Operating Model, shown in the following HOBA® Analysis/Design pyramid, with ‘pilot’ sitting in the last step, having understood this:

The Pilot is testing the design developed down the right handside of the Analysis-Design Pyramid - the TOM 👍
The Pilot is testing the design developed down the right handside of the Analysis-Design Pyramid - the TOM 👍

Issues Faced With Piloting

Organisations often treat pilots as a ‘testing ground’ only and do not go into necessary ‘details’ of the project (i.e. only test a subset of the full solution, or part of the end-to-end process, and not the full breath of the final solution nor end to end process).

This will inhibit the transformation to springboard for a full–blown solution (and implementation) later. Without the necessary ‘details’, the pilot will be limited in its effectiveness and will ultimately cause it to fail to gather full support from the whole organization.

Pilots also can have the tendency to not measure the associated costs and revenues before and after the implementation of the pilot.

Hence, it becomes difficult to determine the tangible Return On Investment (ROI) for the full and final implemented solution. 

The pilot needs to be designed so that it tests the most contentious risk areas. 

Regardless of the business process or technology that is sought to be implemented, the risk evaluation needs to be reasonable so that there is level of confidence with the level of risk that will be carried forward to a full implementation project.

The main reason for resistance to piloting is the lack of knowledge within the Organisation about the benefits of piloting and what it actually involves.

The Business Architect (we call Business Transformers – because a Business Transformator has moved beyond Designer, to include part Strategiser, part Collaborator and part Negotiator), therefore, has to keep in mind:

To mitigate the resistance to Piloting, HOBA® includes pilots by default in its own building block to get visibility and attention for MVPs.

This ensures the Organisation’s capabilities and implementation options are both visible (i.e. stakeholders are informed and aware of it, mostly because they were involved in designing it, or reported to of its progress), and are tested before any decision is made about full implementation.

Business Transformation 101

Business Transformation 101

Confused where to start? Get started right 👉

👏 "The biggest obstacle to change is not process or technology, it is employees." 🚧👥 #ChangeManagement #EmployeeEngagement

The Keys To A Successful Pilot

No matter how well a pilot project looks good on paper there will are always a few obstacles to avoid, and a few keys to making a successful pilot.

Here are the keys to making a successful pilot:

Looking for the Best Training to deliver your Business Transformation? Search no more!

Looking for the Best Training-7 Day FREE Trial

👏 "The HOBA framework - the world's first and only business-led agile business transformation framework. Leading the way in business transformation." 🌐 #HOBA #BusinessAgility


In conclusion, the blog post “To Pilot Your Business Transformation or Not, That Is the Question” provides a comprehensive exploration of the role and importance of piloting in business transformation. It emphasises the need for accurate risk identification post-pilot execution and the significance of stakeholder and expectation management.

The post also highlights the role of employees in the success or failure of transformations, and the need for a balanced focus on both business processes and technology.

HOBA Tech’s role in business transformation is also discussed, with mentions of its trusted status among the UK Government, FTSE-100 companies, and start-ups. The post provides insights into the 6-step agile transformation framework and the importance of reasonable risk evaluation.

Wrap Up

For more insights into business transformation, you can explore the following resources:

For more insights into business transformation, you can explore the following resources:

To learn more about how HOBA Tech can assist with your business transformation needs, contact us.

Hope you got a lot of value of out of it, thanks for reading!



Heath Gascoigne

P.S. If you want to join our Business Transformator community of 2,000+ like-minded Business Transformators, join the community on the Business Transformator Facebook Group here.

P.P.S. If you want to learn more about the world’s only business-led business transformation framework, check out The Business Transformation Playbook here.

For more information, visit https://hoba.tech

Share and Enjoy !

Heath Gascoigne

Heath Gascoigne

Hi, I'm Heath, the founder of HOBA TECH and host of The Business Transformation Podcast. I help Business Transformation Consultants, Business Designers and Business Architects transform their and their clients' business and join the 30% club that succeed. Join me on this journey.

Can't get enough real insights? Subscribe to Transformology®!​

We’ll send jargon free insights that you can actually use to transform your business straight to your inbox once a week. 

Work Smarter, not Harder!

Subscribe to Transformology®

Connect with Us


The British Business Awards - Small-Business-Influencer-of-the-Year 2024

HOBA TECH founder Heath Gascoigne featured in – The MBA Entrepreneur: From school to

Read More »
Essential Skills for Effective Business Transformation: A Comprehensive Guide

Enterprise architecture frameworks play a crucial role in guiding organisations through the complex process

Read More »
Meet the Board Members - Myles Hopkins and Ruben Pinan

HOBA TECH founder Heath Gascoigne featured in – The MBA Entrepreneur: From school to

Read More »
Business Transformation Training - HOBA Is different

Become a Master of Business Transformation

Learn about Business-led Business Transformation
using the proven 6-step agile transformation framework
trusted by the UK Government, FTSE-100 and
fast growing companies

What's HOBA®?

HOBA® is the new way to transform organisations and the answer to the 70% failure rate of business and digital transformation projects today.

Learn more about HOBA®

Are you a consultant,
team or organisation
embarking on your
transformation and
want to move from the
model of transforming

Join our free webinar
and learn ‘How to
maximum the return
on your
improve service
delivery with less
effort, less time & cost
and increased profits!’

AGILE 1.0 ... 2.0

Successful Business Transformation starts here

More Articles

The Business Transformation Industry is Broken - Elephant in the Room 🤫
Heath Gascoigne

Business Transformation Industry is Broken

Why The Business Transformation Industry Is Broken? Before I show you how to transform your business, let’s define business transformation. What Is Business Transformation? Business Transformation is when a business changes the way it conducts business. It doesn’t necessarily change what it does, but how it does it.This can involve a change […]

Read More »
Overcoming the Business Architecture Challenge
Heath Gascoigne

The Business Architecture Challenge

Let’s start this post by defining business architecture. What Is Business Architecture? Business architecture refers to an organization’s framework. The Business Architecture Working Group of the Object Management Group (OMG), calls it “a blueprint of the enterprise that provides a common understanding of the organization and is used to align strategic objectives and tactical […]

Read More »
What is Enterprise Architecture Anyway? 🤓
Heath Gascoigne

What Is Enterprise Architecture Really?

Let’s start this post by defining enterprise architecture… What Is Enterprise Architecture? Enterprise Architecture looks at both Business and Technology Architecture. TechTarget calls it “a conceptual blueprint that defines the structure and operation of an organization”.Its aims to make sure your IT investment will help you achieve your current and future objectives at the […]

Read More »
Vector Globe Design for Business Transformation

Get content like this sent directly to your inbox!

Scroll to Top

Master Business Transformation with Our Free Guide!

Discover the 6 Essential Steps

Gain access to our ebook ‘6-steps to business transformation success,’ a condensed version of our renowned bestseller ‘The Business Transformation Playbook.’ Learn the strategies trusted by the UK Government, top companies, and thousands of practitioners worldwide to initiate, execute, and scale successful business transformations

By downloading the 6-Steps ebook you will be subscribing to the HOBA Tech newsletter

Webinar has eneded, Join Waitlist

The Webinar has ended and Please join waitlist to contact with us.

Apologies, The Scorecard is currently down!

We are working to get it restored. Leave your details below to be notified when we got it back up again!

HOBA Tech Transformation Results

Wait! Don't Leave Empty Handed!

Stay Updated with Our Latest Content

Sign up now and never miss out on valuable content and exclusive offers


This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website.